Amy Renee Mihaljevic Murder: Decades-old unsolved kidnapping and murder case resurfaces

In a chilling and tragic incident that still sends shivers down the spine, 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic was reportedly enticed into a Cleveland, Ohio mall and abducted on October 27, 1989. The young fifth-graders last moments were witnessed by two of her classmates at the Village Square shopping center. After an extensive search, her decomposed remains

In a chilling and tragic incident that still sends shivers down the spine, 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic was reportedly enticed into a Cleveland, Ohio mall and abducted on October 27, 1989. The young fifth-grader’s last moments were witnessed by two of her classmates at the Village Square shopping center. After an extensive search, her decomposed remains were discovered nearly four months later in a field roughly 50 miles from the mall. A stab wound to the neck had claimed her life, according to The Cinemaholic.

Amy’s ordeal began when her abductor made contact with her through a telephone call. Luring her with the promise of needing help to buy a gift for his recently-promoted mother, he orchestrated a meeting that would tragically alter the course of Amy’s life. This sinister episode wasn’t isolated—detectives revealed that two other young girls had received similar calls around the same time. Despite the passing of decades, the case remains unresolved, leaving a haunting trail of questions.

On August 30, 2023, a fresh episode of “Dateline: Unforgettable” on Oxygen is set to delve into the disturbing events surrounding Amy Mihaljevic’s alleged kidnapping and murder. The episode, titled “What Happened to Amy?”, is scheduled to air at 8:00 pm ET. The synopsis for the upcoming segment sheds light on the enduring mystery:

“For over 30 years, Ohio investigators have pursued answers in the tragic murder of 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic. The chilling details of the case continue to haunt Josh Mankiewicz and the dedicated investigators, who appeal for assistance in solving this unsettling crime.”

People magazine reported that Amy began receiving mysterious calls from an unidentified man shortly before her vanishing. Convinced to meet the stranger at Village Square Shopping Center in Bay Village, Ohio, Amy’s fate was sealed on October 27, 1989.

Eyewitnesses, two of Amy’s classmates, reported seeing a white male, approximately in his 30s, approach her. He placed his hand on her shoulder and led her through the shopping center’s parking lot, setting off alarm bells for her parents who promptly reported her disappearance to the police. The ensuing search, one of the largest in Ohio’s history, involved numerous law enforcement agencies.

Tragically, the investigation concluded on February 8, 1990, when a jogger stumbled upon Amy’s decomposed remains in an Ashland County field, miles away from where she was last seen. The cause of her death was a single stab wound to the neck. Detectives uncovered disturbing patterns—Amy was likely killed shortly after being abducted, and similar calls were made to other young girls around that time.

Sgt. Jay Elish of the Bay Village Police Department expressed the difficulty in comprehending the perpetrator’s motives:

7:20 a.m. appx.
Amy Mihaljevic leaves home for Bay Square Middle School in Bay Village, Ohio on her blue bike.
She is wearing short black boots and her favorite earrings – silver and turquoise horse heads. #Dateline pic.twitter.com/TevsqCNIBZ

— Dateline Producer (@DatelineNBCProd) September 17, 2021

“We don’t know if he was grooming anybody that would bite. Or if it was somebody that may have met Amy. That’s one of the things we’ve been trying to determine for years.”

Connecting the dots, investigators discovered that Amy and the other girls had visited the Lake Erie Nature and Science Center. Missing items and evidence, like her distinctive turquoise horse-head earrings, black ankle boots, and a binder with “Buick, Best in Class” imprinted, further fueled the mystery. Additionally, a white blanket and an olive-green curtain found near the crime scene held hairs from both Amy and her dog.

Despite an array of tips and interviews with multiple suspects, the case has remained stubbornly unsolved for decades, leaving Amy’s family and investigators haunted by unanswered questions. The upcoming episode of “Dateline: Unforgettable” promises to shine a spotlight on this enduring mystery, hoping to uncover long-awaited answers.

ncG1vNJzZmiin5fAo7vTrGWcp51krq7FjKucp52VYrqqtMCloZ6umZh6rsHRnZyrZZSasKKwxKxkqKSUYsKvv86lrZ6cXaC2pbrAqaeippdirq%2BwjKasq5yVp3qkrdKeZKudo6q%2Fp63Cnqpo

 Share!